Skip to content

7 of The Best Synthetic Ponytails for Natural Hair

Black girl with a ponytail

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read our full disclaimer here.

Hey bestie, it’s your Internet BFF, Kaylannk here! Let’s talk synthetic ponytails.

Looking for affordable hair extensions that also match your natural hair texture is a tedious task. Synthetic options often fall flat. It either looks too shiny, too fake, or the texture just simply does not match. I am here to save you time and money with this post. It features 7 of the best synthetic ponytails that match natural hair. Get instant length and versatility, without sacrificing authenticity.



  1. Freetress Equal Synthetic Ponytail – Natural Girl (Med Rod): This ponytail is a go-to for a flawless look that is sure to turn heads anywhere you go. This ponytail mimics the look and feel of natural hair that is stretched and curled with hair mousse and medium sized rollers. 

2. Sensationnel Drawstring Ponytail Instant Pony Curls Kinks N Co Rain Maker: This ponytail is all about drama and volume. This blowout with curls look is perfect for adding instant height and length to your ponytail. Just be sure to fluff it out for a desired look.

3. Shake N Go Synthetic Organique Ponytail – Body Wave 24″: This ponytail is a serious statement. It adds volume, movement, and length to your look. Be ready to get endless compliments with this easy-to-use ponytail.

4. Sensationnel Instant Pony – Afro Puff Large: This Afro puff ponytail delivers! The kinky-coily texture blends seamlessly with type 4 hair. Just fluff this puff and go! No one will ever know it’s not your hair.

5. Outre Pretty QuickPony – Neesha Body Wave: This is the perfect hair extension for a sleek and high ponytail when your hair is straightened. The texture is a near-perfect match to natural hair that is blown out. Plus, it has a body wave curl that gives an added touch that you did not know you needed.


6. Sensationnel Curls Kinks & Co Synthetic Ponytail Instant Pony – Rule Breaker: This ponytail is great for everyday use. This curly puff style is perfect for adding instant height and, even, color to your hair. It is a look that you can wear any and everywhere.

7. Sensationnel Curls Kinks & Co Synthetic Ponytail Instant Pony – Game Changer XL: This ponytail is a game-changer, indeed. The tight kinky texture blends seamlessly with your natural coils and the length lets you instantly meet your hair goals. Get ready for a bouncy, long ponytail that resembles long healthy natural hair.

Bonus Tip: Wrap a strand of your own hair around the base of the ponytail with a bobby pin to effortlessly blend the ponytail with your natural hair.

Remember, the key to finding the perfect ponytail to match your hair is to consider your curl pattern and desired look.

Written with lots of care, 


Your Internet BFF

P.S. Don’t forget to share your favorite synthetic ponytails in the comments below.

Check out: 5 Best-Selling Outre Half Wigs Are Now Back In Stock


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.